US strategists seek Afghan fixes outside the box | The Daily Star
12:00 AM, September 26, 2010 / LAST MODIFIED: 12:00 AM, September 26, 2010

US strategists seek Afghan fixes outside the box

On a Nato base in Kabul, a five-member team is rethinking the war in Afghanistan and questioning some of the basic assumptions behind the effort to clean up corruption and gain the upper hand over the Taliban.
Among the ideas this so-called "Red Team" is generating: Accept that Afghanistan's entrenched system of graft won't change overnight, so pick your battles, recognise that for Afghans, some corruption is worse than others, so tackle what affects them day-to-day first, and study how the Taliban won power by exploiting Afghanistan's system of payoffs and patronage in the 1990s, and borrow those tactics.
The Red Team's studies are part of an evolution of thinking among diplomats, commanders and analysts alike that applying Western standards to combat corruption has not produced results fast enough.
Further, concentrating on what is most important to Americans -- such as raiding Afghan government offices over large-scale abuses -- has served only to alienate the government of President Hamid Karzai. Such raids have done little to erase the nickel-and-dime bribes Afghans have to pay to drive down a highway, or see a government doctor -- the daily shakedowns that drive the people into the arms of the insurgents, who provide similar services without the graft.
The Taliban, meanwhile, have used the Afghan government's behavior, and Nato's paralysis over the issue, to their advantage. The militants are seen as providing "cleaner" government in areas they control. And they pay off or intimidate local leaders and warlords behind the scenes, as they did the last time they took power.
Net result: Nato is losing this fight.
It's unwelcome news that presents no easy answers for those trying to craft a new strategy to combat corruption. But the Red Team's job is to challenge the status quo, at the direction of the day-to-day commander of operations, Lt. Gen. David Rodriguez.
The Red Team itself is a concept that was developed at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, and was used effectively in Iraq.
They call themselves "cognitive insurgents," fighting the established system with brainpower rather than firepower. Team leader Lt Col Brian Hammerness says they spend "a lot of time balancing" their analysis so commanders on the receiving end don't shoot the messenger. Hammerness often approaches his bosses saying, "I want to present this information to you, and you might not take this well."
For instance, if a local leader is lining his pockets but also cooperating with the Nato-led force, getting him fired may leave a void for the Taliban to fill, says senior analyst Lt Col Michael McGee.
"Sometimes there's a trade-off there," he said. "Initially, you think you are doing the right thing, but it turns out to be much worse than if you'd just left the situation alone."
Some of the Red team's ideas seem to be getting attention. Its report on how the Taliban seized power in the 1990s -- by building a network of dependencies with public officials -- is required reading for commanders who want to re-evaluate how US troops are prosecuting the war, and how a Western strategy can be tailored to Afghan culture.
The team studied how the Taliban first organized, as a motley crew of locals and returned refugees who had studied at religious schools in Pakistan led by Mullah Omar, the future Taliban leader. Taliban members then worked their way into territory of the Pashtuns, Afghanistan's largest ethnic group, by expanding their influence until they were strong enough to take and hold Kabul by force, in 1996.
The Taliban capitalized on local anger at the violent excesses of feudal warlords, offering similar, often superior government-like services, explained lead report author Capt. Jeffrey Marrs.
"They would co-opt regional power-brokers by ... going to their power-base, which is the people," added team member Lt Col Bruce Ferrell. "They would sever the link of patronage."

Stay updated on the go with The Daily Star News App. Click here to download it for your device.

fifa world cup

Grameenphone and Robi:
Type START <space> BR and send SMS it to 2222

Banglalink:
Type START <space> BR and send SMS it to 2225

Leave your comments

Top News

Top News

Top