AI-generated imagery: Democratising art or demolishing aspirations? | The Daily Star
Skip to main content
T
Friday, September 29, 2023
The Daily Star
E-paper Today's News বাংলা
  • Home
  • News
    • Bangladesh
      • Investigative Stories
    • Investigative Stories
    • Asia
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Culture
  • Life & Living
  • Youth
  • Tech & Startup
  • Multimedia
  • Feature
    • Lifestyle
    • Rising Star
    • Showbiz
    • My Dhaka
    • Satireday
    • Campus
    • Toggle
    • Star Literature
    • In Focus
    • Star Youth
    • Shift
    • Daily Star Books
    • Roundtables
    • Star Holiday
    • weekend read
  • More
    • Environment
    • NRB
    • Supplements
    • Law & Our Rights
  • E-paper
  • বাংলা
Search Epaper T
  • Today's News
  • Home
  • News
    • Bangladesh
    • Investigative Stories
    • Asia
    • World
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Culture
  • Life & Living
  • Youth
  • Tech & Startup
  • Multimedia
  • Feature
    • Lifestyle
    • Rising Star
    • Showbiz
    • My Dhaka
    • Satireday
    • Campus
    • Toggle
    • Star Literature
    • In Focus
    • Star Youth
    • Shift
    • Daily Star Books
    • Roundtables
    • Star Holiday
    • weekend read
  • More
    • Environment
    • NRB
    • Supplements
    • Law & Our Rights

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Apps
  • Comment Policy
  • RSS
  • Sitemap
  • Advertisement
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy Policy
  • Conference Hall
  • Archives
SHOUT
Abir Hossain
Thu Aug 11, 2022 06:00 AM
Last update on: Fri Aug 12, 2022 11:15 PM

Most Viewed

  • BB moves to stem slide in reserve

  • Shakib likens Tamim's behaviour to a child's antics

  • Bashundhara seeks to invest in Teletalk

  • ‘Nasty game, not injury, behind my exclusion’

SHOUT

AI-generated imagery: Democratising art or demolishing aspirations?

Abir Hossain
Thu Aug 11, 2022 06:00 AM Last update on: Fri Aug 12, 2022 11:15 PM
Dystopian Buriganga river with alien fish flying – generated using Midjourney
Dystopian Buriganga river with alien fish flying – generated using Midjourney

The limitations of artificial intelligence seem to be disappearing right before our eyes. What started as a tool to automate arduous labour seems to have edged into sci-fi territory, except it has permeated through the silver screen and surpassed the realm of fiction. Ideas that would take hours to execute and years of craftsmanship to master are being condensed by a computer to mere minutes. With the launch of Dall-E and Midjourney, what we know about creativity and AI has changed by leaps and bounds.

According to OpenAI, the developers of Dall-E, the gist is that it "starts with a bag of dots and fills in a pattern with greater and greater detail." The process is vastly different from what artists practice. This begs the question: if the process of creating is snatched away, can it still really be considered an "art piece"? The intent behind what is being created is significant. It is the amalgamation of many artistic techniques, expertly crafted to send a message that makes art. Yet, AI seems to have no problem replicating such artistic feats.

For all latest news, follow The Daily Star's Google News channel.

Tamzid Farhan Mogno, architect and motion designer, reflects on the value of sentiment in art, "I think the most valuable aspect of art is human emotion. We've seen a rise of procedurally generated art mass produced for selling such as NFTs. These quickly become soulless trends and lose value very fast as the novelty fades away."

Football match between humans and aliens at Wembley Stadium – generated using Midjourney
Football match between humans and aliens at Wembley Stadium – generated using Midjourney

He continues, "There are online marketplaces for selling prompts, like promptbase.com, which is absurd and logical at the same time since Dall-E now charges money for generating images for every single prompt. You may find an already generated Dall-E image on that marketplace that matches your style and spend money to find out the keywords used on that prompt. This knowledge of 'prompt engineering' is now becoming somewhat of an expertise for Dall-E users."

While almost anyone can write down a prompt and have the tool conjure up images, those with technical expertise and knowledge of art history will have an upper hand. The conversation then shifts to ownership laws and copyright issues. With questions arising primarily about the intellectual property of the generated image. In the case of Dall-E, they have recently given full copyright to individual users.

Junaid Iqbal Ishmam, Animator at Mighty Punch Studios, says, "One cannot claim the images generated by the AI as their own. Instead, they can take ownership of the idea. The way I view it, when a comic gets published, the story belongs to the author and the credit of the artwork goes to the artist."

Read more

Does this hint at the death of art?

For the time being, neither Dall-E nor Midjourney creates images that can be used commercially. Both manufacture results that still conform to the uncanny valley theory. Some close inspection reveals underlying flaws in the output. The AI cannot get text right, the fingers look jagged, and most conspicuously, it doesn't bode well with positions mentioned in the prompt. But with research progressing at an unprecedented rate, such shortcomings will inevitably be fixed.

Asifur Rahman, concept and comic book artist, dwells on the limitations of AI-generated images, "The ability to produce new images depends on existing libraries of other artists, which is indicative that these tools are devoid of independent thought."

Nevertheless, it has sparked discussion about how AI can aid artists in their workflow, by helping to brainstorm ideas, create reference images, or visualise products. Tamzid believes the real power of these AI tools is the almost infinite possibility of never-before-seen images that can be produced with terrifying speed.

Nawab Sirajuddaula winning Battle of Plassey against the British – generated using Midjourney
Nawab Sirajuddaula winning Battle of Plassey against the British – generated using Midjourney

Asif adds, "I have personally used AI tools to speed up my workflow and come up with rough blockings for my paintings. I think most of AI usage will be in conceptualising and brainstorming rather than creating finished pieces."

As harrowing as this tool is, artists are here to stay. Whether they use it to enhance their work is up to them but given the time and resources, a human who has devoted years to perfecting their skills will create something superior to Dall-E or Midjourney.

Junaid reaffirms that artwork created by people will always have demand. He claims, "AI-generated art could become its own genre or a medium. To generate a well-composed piece, one must have a grasp of fundamental basics of art, for which, we will still require artists."

Read more

Can artificial intelligence be biased?

There are, of course, ethical implications of the tool. The data that Dall-E and Midnourney draw from has an inclination for Eurocentric standards and perpetuates dated biases. an earlier study of Dall-E generated images of exclusively white men when it was prompted with "CEO".

With each new piece of technology that has been introduced to artists, they have coped. This tool is a testament to the fact that human creativity knows no bounds. Without the labour of the many engineers who have created this, and the artists who contributed data, such an achievement could not even be envisioned.

Shine on you crazy diamond Lucy in the sky – generated using Midjourney
Shine on you crazy diamond Lucy in the sky – generated using Midjourney

Asif draws parallels between the visual arts and music. He says, "Voice synthesisers and auto-tune tools have been available for years and it has to a certain degree, democratised music. But only a handful of people know how to utilise such tools to their full potential. More people are making music with ease but that doesn't mean musical knowledge and devotion have become irrelevant."

"Just a decade ago most of us were just consumers on the internet. Now everyone has the access to create their content and publish them. That didn't collapse the film and video industry. Similarly, the new ability to create nuanced images by anyone, won't take away the value of the creativity to make something out of those images," Tamzid concludes.

Abir Hossain has failed enough captcha tests to be classified as a robot. Remind him what traffic lights look like at [email protected] 

Related topic:
Artificial Intelligence (AI)youthArt
Apple Google
Click to comment

Comments

Comments Policy

Related News

Is AI the solution to the animation industry’s so-called “labour shortage”?

Our theatre scene and its present challenges

Our theatre scene and its present challenges

Which artist do you fancy?

Which artist do you fancy?

5 art galleries you can visit in Dhaka

5 art galleries you can visit in Dhaka

Study playlist

Making a study playlist that works for you

হাছান মাহমুদ
|রাজনীতি

বিএনপি-জামায়াত বিশ্ববেনিয়াদের হাতে দেশকে তুলে দিতে চায়: হাছান মাহমুদ

হাছান মাহমুদ বলেন, বিএনপি বাংলাদেশকে আন্তর্জাতিক রাজনীতির ক্রীড়াক্ষেত্রে পরিণত করতে চায়।

৪১ মিনিট আগে
|রাজনীতি

রংপুরে প্রধানমন্ত্রীর জন্মদিনের অনুষ্ঠানে আ. লীগের ২ গ্রুপের সংঘর্ষ, আহত শতাধিক

১ ঘণ্টা আগে
Please Click on allow
The Daily Star
Journalism without fear or favour
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Apps
  • Comment Policy
  • RSS
  • Sitemap
  • Advertisement
  • Newsletter
  • Privacy Policy
  • Conference Hall
  • Archives
© 2023 thedailystar.net | Powered by: RSI LAB
Copyright: Any unauthorized use or reproduction of The Daily Star content for commercial purposes is strictly prohibited and constitutes copyright infringement liable to legal action.
X