NRC: A test for Modi’s ‘sabka viswas’ vision
On June 26, the controversial National Register of Citizens (NRC) in Assam was pruned down considerably. The names of slightly over one lakh people were deleted from the final draft document of the 1951 document that is being updated on an order of the Supreme Court to weed out illegal immigrants from the state. The exclusion of the latest names from the NRC was announced by the Assam coordinator of the NRC, thereby swelling the number of those kept out of the document to more than 41 lakh. The final NRC draft published on July 30 last year excluded 40,07,707 persons out of which a little over 3.6 million filed claims against their exclusion. And the latest exclusion of 102,462 people was the result of the scrutiny of those claims.
According to the state coordinator for NRC, those in the new exclusion list, which came a little over a month before the Apex Court-set deadline for publication of the final NRC, will be informed individually through letters to be delivered at their residential addresses along with the reason of exclusion after which they can file claims against the dropping of their names and the hearings of their claims will start on July 5.
The coordinator cited the reasons for the exclusion in three categories. One, those who are declared "foreigner", doubtful voter or persons with cases pending at Foreigners' Tribunals, a quasi-judicial body, or their descendants, as applicable, discovered after publication of the final draft NRC in July last year. Two, persons who were found to be ineligible while appearing as witness in hearings held for disposal of claims and objections. There is a third category of people who were found to be ineligible during the process of verification carried out by the Local Registrars of Citizens under provisions of Clause 4(3), post publication of the final NRC draft. As per the clause, the local registrar, before the final publication of NRC, may take up verification of such persons. And according to NRC officials, the latest exclusion is the result of the continuing process of re-verification of the names in the final NRC draft. There is no official word on the breakup of the people as per their religious identities in the latest list of one lakh people excluded.
The Supreme Court, which is monitoring the process of updating the NRC, had ordered that those declared foreigners and their descendants are to be kept out of the NRC while the names of doubtful voters and persons who have cases pending in Foreigners' Tribunals are to be kept on hold till their cases are decided by the tribunals, irrespective of them clearing the NRC verification processes. The absence of a common database means thousands of declared foreigners, doubtful voters and persons who have cases pending found their names in the final draft NRC. The exercise of addition or deletion of names in the NRC is not new. For instance, when the first draft of the NRC was made public on December 31, 2017, it had 1.90 crore names but the final draft that came out in July 2018 deleted the names of 1.5 lakh out of the 1.90 crore.
So, what is the total number of people who could be left out of the final NRC in July this year? NRC officials do not rule out fresh exclusion or inclusion in the final NRC. In the case of exclusion, these would be among the two lakh persons who were included among the 2.89 crore names in the final draft NRC published in July 2018 but against whom "objections" were filed by other people later. If these people cannot prove their citizenship with proper documents, they run the risk of being left out of the final NRC to come out on July 31 this year. But this is not the end of the road for those excluded. They can move the Foreigners' Tribunal which has to take a decision within 120 days, as per an order of the home ministry issued in May this year. The legal course for those aggrieved by the Foreigners' Tribunal does not end there as they can move the High Court and the Supreme Court for redress.
In the case of inclusion, if claims for inclusion of names in the NRC are backed by requisite papers, the number of 41 lakh kept out of the document would come down. However, if objections to inclusion of names are held valid, they can further push up the number of those excluded. The final number of those kept out of the NRC may also vary if some of them can get Indian citizenship under the Citizenship Amendment Bill proposed to be moved by Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government.
It is interesting to note that while the NRC aims at keeping out "illegal immigrants" in Assam irrespective of their religion, the Citizenship Amendment Bill seeks to give citizenship to "persecuted" religious minorities from Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan. The difficulty is that the Bill is dead. After being passed by the Lok Sabha during the first five-year term of the Modi government, the previous Bill could not be tabled in the Rajya Sabha where ruling Bharatiya Janata Party lacked majority. The BJP has promised to introduce a fresh Citizenship Amendment Bill in the new Lok Sabha even though as of today, the party lacks the arithmetic to guarantee its approval in the upper house of parliament. However, the saffron party has a comfortable majority in the Lok Sabha to ensure the Bill's passage there.
One thing is clear: the NRC and the Citizenship Amendment Bill bring out the identity politics in Assam by being juxtaposed with each other. It remains to be seen if this will be in sync with Modi's addition of "sabka viswas"—which refers to his party's efforts to secure the trust of religious minorities—to his earlier call of "sabka saath sabka vikas." By bringing in "sabka viswas", Modi has set the bar much higher for a test of his inclusive vision of India and he has to keep this in mind while taking forward the NRC project to reaffirm the Hindutva politics.
Finally, there remain two key questions: what will be the status of those left out of the final NRC in July this year? And how does the government plan to deal with them? Many who do not find their names in the final draft of NRC have their names in the voters' list in Assam and have voted in the recent parliamentary election. But will they lose their voting rights if they are out of the final NRC? Will they, irrespective of their religion, be able to claim Indian citizenship in any state other than Assam? Earlier a view had emerged that these people should have their basic rights protected and be given work permits but their political rights be taken away.
Pallab Bhattacharya is a special correspondent for The Daily Star.
Follow The Daily Star Opinion on Facebook for the latest opinions, commentaries and analyses by experts and professionals.
To contribute your article or letter to The Daily Star Opinion, see our guidelines for submission.