Making finance resilient to the smallholder farmers
Brig Gen Shahedul Anam Khan ndc, psc (Retd), Moderator of the session
We are still a heavily agro-based society and economy. Perhaps the most neglected are those that are feeding this economy – the farmers. Because of the absence of available facilities from the financial organisations, farmers suffer. We hope that we can bring out some pointers today to help achieve the goals of today's discussion.
Prabodh Dakota, Assistant Country Director, CARE Bangladesh
Smallholder farmers are usually skeptical about loans due to factors such as unpredictable prices, frequency of natural disasters, etc., that put their crops at risk. However, they are also aware that though repaying schemes are difficult, many farmers can still benefit from such schemes.
We need to look into how the government, private sector, and the development partners can, through their collective efforts, transform the lives of smallholder farmers.
Maruf Azam, General Manager, Krishi Utsho, CARE Bangladesh
The smallholder farmers don't have proper access to capital, the capital doesn't reach them in a systematic way and the capital that they obtain is too costly. Natural calamities affect crop production. Quality inputs – for example, fertilisers, seeds, insecticides, food for domestic animals – that they use are adulterated. The transaction cost is very high making it quite impossible for them to reach a certain level using their own distribution channels. Moreover, they lack information and knowledge about mechanisation and modern technologies that can help to efficiently cultivate crops.
To tackle these challenges, in 2016, CARE Bangladesh launched "Krishi Utsho". It aims to make quality agricultural resource available for the marginal smallholder farmers.
There are informal intermediaries who are the market actors and cannot be removed from the whole process. So, we thought of transforming these intermediaries. In that way, they can provide good quality inputs without having to increase the price, while maintaining the quality of life they hope to achieve along with a good profit. We monitor a network for the agricultural input sellers or smallholder shop owners of the rural areas and provide them with adequate training and help them identify the right products. If we accommodate female-friendly schemes, it would benefit the society of marginal farmers a lot.
Ahsan Habib, Professor and Director (Training), Bangladesh Institute of Bank Management (BIBM)
When farmers harvest their crops and store it, it becomes risky for the people, as they might start feeding themselves from the portion stored for the people. So we are forcing them systematically, to sell the crops, and repay the loan as soon as possible. Bangladesh Bank extended the loan repayment period for farmers to six months. But the risk for me increases as the goods are still with the farmer. We are taking the money from farmers, giving it to the middlemen who are buying those crops, and storing it in their warehouse. The intermediaries are benefitting from all those institutional finances. Warehouse Receipt System can be introduced to overcome this problem. A commodity market is also required at the same time though that will be difficult to implement.
Promoting farmers' cooperatives is required besides proper cluster financing. However, cluster financing has still not been properly identified. Moreover, the smallholder farmers' services should be considered as public goods because they are producing 80 percent of the food.
Dr Swapan Kumar Bala, Commissioner, Bangladesh Securities and Exchange Commission (BSEC)
The primary requirement for commodity exchange has not been fulfilled yet. There are insufficient numbers of warehouses for this. Quality testing is required, which will ensure its securitisation. This security will then become tradeable in the secondary market. It is delivered from the warehouse when the final consumer decides to take it. However, securitisation can cause maturity mismatch. Mass awareness is required about this process. Agreements like collateral management agreement or storage monitoring agreement need to be securitised, to make the exit easy. Introducing Warehouse Receipt System may enhance transparency within the process. A separate regulation for commodity exchange should be authorised.
Md Ahsan Ul Alam, SVP and Head-Agent Banking, Bank Asia
The agricultural input market is good, but the problem lies in the output market, due to which the farmers are not receiving fair pricing. A formal chain should be there which the government, private, and development organisations can help create.
The need for monitoring causes costs to increase when financing farmers. If banks are forced to stay within single digit interest rates even after these costs, they will not be able to compete with informal banking, and will no longer be sustainable.
Milton Roy, Head-Agent Banking, NRB Bank
Easy access to banks has been provided to farmers and ordinary people through the introduction of agent banking, since the agents are locals. However, this makes it difficult to identify the real farmers. Insurance helps mitigate risks concerning weather and climate, but if a strong market monitoring facility in Bangladesh is not implemented, insurance will become useless.
Using advanced technology can increase production but our farmers are still not receiving this technology. Farmers' skills development programmes are also necessary.
Ali Tareque Parvez, SVP, Agriculture Insurance Team, Green Delta Insurance Company Ltd
There is a 15 percent VAT on every insurance product, which should be reduced for the agricultural sector. This VAT causes premium rates to increase from two percent to three percent, which is unreasonably high for farmers.
Everything related to resilience financing and climate change issues is insurable. The entire supply chain can also be insured, but the issue is with pricing index. This would require a benchmark, since these matters are controlled by the government. The government can also provide back-end support to the financial institutions through funds or common pools.
Md Nazmul Hasan, Head-Agent Banking, BRAC Bank Ltd
Small-ticket loans already have an interest rate below 10, so banks don't earn here. Hence, agricultural financing is done through MFIs. The lack of distribution channels is another obstacle. The introduction of agent banking has opened up a channel and access.
A digital lending approach is required in loan processing, through which on-time loan delivery will be possible. When giving out loans, banks are worried about the certainty of repayment within the specified period, and also require assurance that the given loan is being used properly. A comprehensive policy is required for this.
Shahnaz Akter Shahin, AVP and Head-ACD, Bank Asia
Banks are now coming forward to reduce transaction costs. They have developed some special products for the SMEs which have reduced their transaction costs significantly. Banks also have some additional or hidden charges which they are no longer implementing for the smallholders or the agricultural borrowers. Smallholder loans have also been digitised to ensure the loan reaches the farmer within 24 hours.
Sajadul Haque, Head-ADC, Pragati Life Insurance Ltd
There is no scope for corporate social responsibility (CSR) in life insurance, since this uses public money. The biggest challenge in selling insurance products is the lack of trust and awareness. People search for insurance only after falling ill, but no policy allows selling insurance to an ill person.
S M Ziaul Hoque, CEO, Chartered Life Insurance Co. Ltd
The primary problem in insurance for farmers is ensuring collateral loans, or setting up a cooperative model. Alternatively, banks and insurance companies can create embedded product insurance, where the loan will be secured by the insurance company. Then, there will be no need to buy insurance separately. Loans targetting farmers for their products can be insured through bundling. The product will receive insurance coverage from non-life insurance companies, while we will provide coverage for the credit.
S M Saiful Islam, Head-Agri Finance, BRAC Bank Ltd
It takes months to obtain permission from Bangladesh Bank for piloting projects because they perceive insurance as a cost, not risk coverage. BB mentioned it was not possible for them to give insurance to farmers that incurs more than nine percent costs, since they only provide agricultural loans of nine percent. Therefore, bundle products are out of the picture. Since BB kept denying permission, we decided to carry out a pilot so that BB could change their decision on the basis of the pilot's results.
Ahmed Aslam Al Ferdous, Head-Agent Banking, Dutch Bangla Bank Ltd (DBBL)
Commercial bankers don't have the expertise to manage agricultural loans, but recently, we were able to send agricultural products to rural areas with the help of agent banking and MFI channels. However, the infrastructural cost is very high as MFI lending interest rate in rural areas goes up to 30 percent cost. At this scale, banks have to bear high costs. Even if liquid MFIs are used, there is still a high interest rate for the agricultural farmers. Banks should individually bring out products specifically for agricultural loans, not influenced by the government only.
Aamanur Rahman, Director-ERPP, CARE Bangladesh
Pre-harvest and post-harvest processes, which are dominated by female workers, are not considered part of farming, which means these processes don't get insurance coverage. If the entire supply chain is covered, gender integration will be possible.
There is pressure on reducing the agricultural loan interest rate from nine percent but even a five percent interest rate is too high for farmers. The government could share risks with the insurance companies.
After approval from BB, we recruit the agents. Some of them are creating farmers' organisations and providing farmers with financial literacy. They are also attempting to change people's attitude towards savings and working to mitigate the challenges farmers face in the market when trying to get good prices for their products. They are also maintaining the output price in the market so that farmers can repay the loan.
Mohammed Shaukat Ali, Chief Risk Officer (Acting), NRB Bank
We are financing the farmers, and ensuring insurance for them as a risk management tool, but we don't have a process for ensuring price. The proposed model has to have a selling perspective to determine sales after the monitoring process. If big companies and supermarkets can prepare a dashboard to monitor the kind of products that are being produced and the expected date of harvesting, further development could help the process reach a level of future contracting.
Saifuddin Ahmed, Adviser-Social Services, CARE Bangladesh
We have to understand the potential capacity that agent banking can reach since it is being used as a vehicle to reach out to farmers or consumers. What are we, the commercial banks, doing to maximise the capacity of the agents?
Kohinoor Akhter, Senior Technical Manager, CARE Bangladesh
Bank agents are entangled in many problems which render it impossible for them to work successfully. No scope is being created for banks to be benefitted by the agents.
Mahfuz Anam, Editor and Publisher, The Daily Star
There are a range of issues involved in helping the smallholder farmers, through insurance, bank loans, and the formula and implementation of those initiatives. We wish to report all these issues, including all the regulatory problems that you face.