And that is exactly why the affair regarding the car demands a close scrutiny. Though there are different versions about how and under what circumstances the car had landed at the high functionary's doorstep, we do not wish to get into the details of the official procedure to try and find out who is right and who isn't. Suffice it to say though, that there are certain stark facts that need to be answered, fairly and squarely. The point is -- was it a gift? If it was, how and why it was? Does it really matter now to debate who the first recipient of the vehicle was since it was being actually used by the minister?

Technical explanations apart, it appeared unethical on any government organisation's or individual's part to have accepted a transport given by an international company. We expect a far more responsible and thoughtful approach to such an offer betraying a certain craving for favour. Ministers and government functionaries need not only to be incorruptible but also must be seen to be so.

We have heard that the government is reportedly 'embarrassed' over the matter and is planning to take action. For our part, we demand a full-scale probe into the affair. This is necessary for the sake of establishing accountability and transparency with regard to something that has come to public notice and put a high government functionary's credibility somewhat on the line in a high-profile field like energy. While the state minister makes a statement for the records, an inquiry into the scandal would be in order.